Why The Dog Has Better Clothes Than I Do

I was raised by a Labrador. I did not see the point of coats for dogs. Then my previous pooch got old and suddenly I was That Person whose dog and horse had matching fleece blankets. I thought that I was making a perfectly reasonable exception to my no-clothes rule for an old dog…

Enter Lilo.

Lilo gets cold. It’s fair, really. She has a short single coat — no insulating undercoat like a Lab or many of the other outdoorsy breeds — and while she generates plenty of body heat, the dog converts hot dogs and string cheese straight into muscle. I wish I had her abs, but she’s just not designed to stay warm in winter at 4,000 feet without some help. This is problem #1.

Lilo on haybale
A young Lilo wearing a Weatherbeeta blanket over a Rambo fleece while helping me at the barn.

She inherited Casey’s horse-blanket-style coats years ago and those worked fine for barn chores and walks around town. She wasn’t a huge fan — to this day, she seems to find fleece itchy — but they did the job. Still do the job, actually: the Weatherbeeta is still in the regular rotation for local strolls and shoulder-season weather. Not bad for a relatively cheap coat acquired 6+ years ago!

pawtuckaway fog
A recent foggy day at Round Pond in Pawtuckaway.

But it pretty quickly became clear that we needed a bigger gun for mountain hikes. I first tried layering, as in the haybale picture above, but with her pack on top…

On Mansfield in October, our first Vermont 4,000-footer. I added the fleece after this pic was taken, but it shows a bit of how the pack and blanket interact.

…it was just too much bulk. Pack + Weatherbeeta worked fine, but with the third layer, she ended up with rubs on her elbows and under the chestpiece. I don’t blame the jackets; they were never designed to be used this way. But clearly we needed to try something different.

We’d also picked up a Fido Fleece along the way, because I wanted her belly covered, but for this dog the theory was better than the execution. As above, she thinks the fleece is itchy and also we have problem #2: that massive pit bull front end.

fido on the hancock
Wearing the fleece alone on the Hancocks…
fido on the beach
…and under the Weatherbeeta at Twin Lights State Park in Maine.

The pup is wide across the chest and through the shoulders and neck, and her front legs have what horse people refer to as “lots of bone.” This is fine and dandy in general, but most technical dog clothes are designed for sporting and herding breeds, not for my happy little monster truck. The Fido Fleece is a relatively mild offender and works well on many, many bully breed dogs — but on Lilo over miles, it rubbed the tops of her front legs pretty raw.

I toned down my ambitions to let her heal and let me think about what to try next. The weather was still quite pleasant at lower elevations, especially closer to home, so we did some local hikes and I swapped out her pack for her old tracking harness (really a S&R vest), which has a different chest strap and puts the belly strap farther back. Lilo doesn’t carry weight in her pack (although it’s a convenient place to stash raingear or hats and gloves) and mostly wears it because I like having a handle on her in case she needs an assist with a scramble. The vest met that requirement handily (see what I did there?) and the more we used it, the more I liked having it close to her body instead of over top of the coat — it seemed less likely to rub or bind that way.

sar vest
S&R vest on otherwise naked dog.

After much research and careful comparison of Lilo’s measurements to the sizing charts, I bit the bullet and ordered her a Hurtta Ultimate Warmer. I’d heard great things about the quality of Hurtta gear in general, wasn’t sure it was quite as warm as I wanted, but liked the ability to cover her haunches and neck and loved that it was literally the only coat out there that seemed like it might be a little too big in the neck and girth measurements. I figured that meant it would actually fit her just right.


moosilauke pose
Posing in her Ultimate Warmer on the ridge between Moosilauke and the south peak.
moosilauke t rex
Plenty of freedom of movement — and no rubs!
hurtta willey
Enjoying that turtleneck on the Willey Range.

She wears the vest under this one and I can grab the handle through one of the leash openings if need be. Of course this also means that warm air can escape through the same opening — but it seems to close pretty well when not in use and I figure it’s an acceptable tradeoff for such a good fit. I also don’t love that the back of the coat is designed to snap under the tail; this covers her thighs nicely, but is, uh, questionable design for a female dog who likes to mark her trail. I tend to leave it either snapped to the sides (functioning like a blanket coat) or snapped together but over her tail (kind of a funny look, but a compromise between warmth and tidiness).

I’ve been really happy with the Ultimate Warmer and am forever in Hurtta’s debt for making a coat that actually! fits! my dog! but have wondered if it’s going to be quuuiiiite warm enough since we seem likely to keep hiking the Whites right on through the winter. Luckily(?), I’ve also ended up with a second technical winter coat through my own boneheadedness; I left the Hurtta somewhere the day before we were supposed to group-hike Waumbek and wasn’t going to be able to get it back until after. So I crossed my fingers and picked up a Ruffwear Powder Hound jacket from a local shop.

ruffwear fireplace
Not into posing on Starr King.
ruffwear tank
Waiting with her buddy for us slowpoke humans to catch up.

My assessment at this point — after one mountain use and one flatland hike — is what I’d expected based on the measurements (and this is a large; the size chart would have put her at the high end of medium but there was no way). This is a great coat designed for a differently-shaped dog. It’s super warm, covers her belly and haunches very nicely, and stays in place well, but is tighter across the chest than I’d like and the sleeved design (while contributing to the warmth) did cause a little broken hair after the Waumbek hike. No damage to the skin and she didn’t seem to mind the fit at all, but I wouldn’t want this to be her only coat. I also hadn’t fully appreciated how well the Hurrta stays in place longitudinally; while it rolls a bit from side-to-side on my barrel-shaped pup, I hadn’t realized that I wasn’t pulling it forward until I found myself having to do so with the Powder Hound.

At this point, we’re sticking with the Ultimate Warmer for Lilo’s go-to winter coat and we’ll see if my concerns about it not being quite enough for really frigid weather are founded. I’m glad to have the Powder Hound and am curious about its potential as a layering piece under the Hurtta to keep her toasty on the winter higher summits; I’ll report back if and when we give it a try. And I can’t say enough good things about the Weatherbeeta for a basic affordable coat. I’m curious whether we’ll ever manage to destroy the thing!


Still working on how best to keep her ears warm, though…



4 thoughts on “Why The Dog Has Better Clothes Than I Do

    1. Aw, thanks! Booties are on my list of things to try, though less for the cold right now than for sharp rocks in non-snowy seasons. She has short enough hair that ice balls aren’t a huge issue and doesn’t seem to mind the cold thus far. If we were out in serious negatives, I’d probably rethink, but she gets cold so easily and I’m trying to keep it fun for her, that’s above our paygrade at this point! We do use Musher’s Secret paw wax when I remember.


  1. My dogs have better clothes than I do, too! ๐Ÿ˜€ It’s so funny because we started out with Weather Beetas, too! I also used to layer them with a fleece underneath and have dealt with the rubbing on the front of their legs by the armpits. We recently got into coats from Hurtta and I can’t say enough good things about them. If you need a second coat from Hurtta I would recommend the Summit Parka. I like that design way better than the Ultimate Warmer. There are no butt flaps to worry about, the back length is adjustable and I think the belly strap on that coat makes the coat more versatile. It’s also just as warm as the Ultimate Warmer. My dogs are really hard to fit, too and the parka works really well for them. ๐Ÿ˜€


    1. Thanks for the comment and that’s interesting! I considered the Summit Parka but didn’t have a good sense of the relative warmth or an opportunity to compare them in person. I hope to not have to buy another coat in the near future, but it’s great to know that, just in case!


Tell Me A Thing

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s